For immigrants arriving to the United States, the American tax system can be a very new and confusing concept. In fact, the tax system in the U.S. is so complex that most natural-born Americans have difficulty filing each year.
In the U.S., everyone with income above certain levels is expected to file a tax return. That’s not true in all countries around the world. In many countries, the government withholds taxes from paychecks, and the individual never has to directly file an income tax return. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) is the U.S. agency responsible for collecting taxes.
Whether you are a lawful permanent resident or an undocumented immigrant, it’s important that you get a basic understanding of your tax obligations and the consequences of where you pay taxes.
Filing U.S. Income Tax as a Permanent Resident
It’s possible to lose your status as a lawful permanent resident based on how you file (or do not file) taxes. It also affects your ability to naturalize as a U.S. citizen.
Maintaining Permanent Residence
There are a couple of common ways that taxes can affect your status as a permanent resident. First, there may be some tax advantages to file your income tax return as a non-resident, but this could adversely affect your immigration status. The IRS has its own way of calculating who is considered a resident versus a nonresident alien. Filing taxes with the IRS as a “non-resident” can lead the government to believe that you are a resident in another country and have abandoned your permanent residence in the United States. Before you file as a non-resident, speak to an immigration attorney.
Likewise, paying taxes in another country could create the presumption that you also reside in that country. One way this issue could be exposed is through a Customs and Border Protection (CBP) interview when re-entering the U.S. The CBP officer may ask if you’ve earned income or paid taxes in another country. If CBP determines that you have been residing in another country, you could find yourself in Immigration Court for removal proceedings.
Naturalizing as a U.S. Citizen
It should go without saying, maintaining your permanent resident status is essential for naturalizing as a U.S. citizen. Additionally, failure to file taxes can negatively affect your ability to naturalize. Eligibility for naturalization requires that you demonstrate good moral character. When preparing Form N-400, Application for Naturalization, you will be asked specific questions about filing taxes. If U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) believes that you have avoided your tax obligations in any way, they will most likely deny the application based on the good moral character requirement.
If you do plan to apply for naturalization and have failed to file tax returns or pay taxes in the past, you can resolve the problem. Enter a payment plan (called an offer in compromise) with the IRS and begin making payments. At your naturalization interview, show the USCIS officer your IRS letter that details the payment plan along with receipts of payments already made against the plan.
Filing U.S. Income Taxes After a Marriage Petition
Taxes can also affect persons that have recently immigrated through marriage to a U.S. citizen or permanent resident. If you recently arrived to the U.S. as a K-1 or K-3 spouse, you should be filing jointly in the next occurring tax filing. When filing Form I-485 to adjust status to permanent resident status on the basis of marriage, you must prove that the marriage is bona fide. You’ll need to submit several documents as evidence of your genuine marriage, and tax documents are critical. USCIS will review your tax returns (for any relevant years) to confirm that they were filed jointly.
After two years as a conditional resident, you’ll need to file Form I-751, Petition to Remove Conditions on Residence. Again, you must establish that you and your spouse have a bona fide marriage. Submitting jointly filed taxed returns is essential evidence to be included with the I-751 petition.
Filing U.S. Income Taxes as an Undocumented Immigrant
Undocumented immigrants include anyone that entered the United States without inspection or overstayed a visa. Regardless of not having a lawful status, there is still an obligation to pay taxes. It’s often “easier” for undocumented immigrants to avoid income taxes. After all, payments are often in cash. But it is possible to pay income taxes, even without a Social Security number. You can obtain an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN) from the IRS to file your taxes.
If you are undocumented, there are very good reasons for you to pay taxes. Paying taxes falls under the concept of good moral character. Being a person of good moral character is very often a criteria for eligibility for various immigration benefits. Should you become eligible for these immigration benefits in the future, payment of taxes contributes to your good moral character.
Cancellation of Removal
In some cases an undocumented immigrant can obtain a green card through cancellation of removal. Certain individuals may be eligible for cancellation of removal after being put into deportation proceedings. Pursuant to INA §240A(b), cancellation of removal is available to a non-permanent resident of the United States in any immigration status who meets all of the following requirements:
- Has been living (continuously physically present) in the United States for at least 10 years; and
- Has been a person of good moral character throughout this time; and
- Has not been convicted of certain crimes or violated certain laws; and
- Establishes that removal would result in “exceptional and extremely unusual hardship” to the alien’s spouse, parent, or child who is a United States citizen or lawful permanent resident.
Generally, a successful cancellation of removal case will also result in the immigrant receiving a green card. However, it’s more complicated that just meeting the requirements. There is a numerical limit on available green cards, and the immigration judge has discretion. Therefore, providing ample evidence (including payment of taxes) is a solid start for demonstrating that you are honest and deserving to be allowed to stay in the U.S. and receive a green card.
There’s also the possibility of future immigration reform that will one day address the millions of undocumented persons in the United States. If and when immigration reform is passed, it’s expected that two major hurdles of eligibility will be proving physical presence and good moral character. A history of filed tax returns is evidence for both of these requirements.
Filing a Petition for a Family Member
If you want to help a family member immigrate to the U.S. and obtain a green card, you will need to act as a sponsor. As a sponsor, you’ll need to file Form I-864, Affidavit of Support. The affidavit of support is required for most family-based immigrants and some employment-based intending immigrants to show that they have adequate means of financial support and are not likely to become a public charge. It’s a contract between a sponsor and the U.S. government, in which the sponsor promises to support the intending immigrant if he or she is unable to do so on their own.
As the sponsor, you must provide evidence that your income is at least 125% of the federal poverty guidelines (with some exceptions). Federal tax returns filed with the IRS are your proof of income.
Not everyone is required to file an income tax return each year. The amount of income that you can earn before you are required to file a tax return depends on the type of income, your age and your filing status. IRS Publication 519 Tax Guide for Immigrants addresses many common tax issues for immigrants. If you are uncertain of your obligations, several resources are available:
- Internal Revenue Service
Certain individuals may be able to prepare and file a tax return for free through the IRS website.
- Online Tax Preparation
Private companies such as TurboTax.com, H&R Block and TaxSlayer.com operate websites with expert software-based tax preparation services. Depending on your tax filing requirements, fees will vary. But in some cases you may be able to prepare for free.
- Professional Services
In-person tax preparation is available from a variety of options. Large systems such as Liberty Tax, H&R Block and Jackson Hewitt have offices throughout the United States. Smaller businesses with very experienced certified public accounts (CPAs) and enrolled agents (EAs) are also typically located in your community.
Many people that have failed to file taxes in the past are pleased to discover that they are owed a tax refund once they finally do file. Know your tax obligations. Again, regardless of your immigration status, it’s important that you get a basic understanding of your tax obligations and how they affect you based on immigration law. And as always, if you are uncertain of how your actions will affect your immigration status, contact an immigration lawyer.
CitizenPath provides simple, affordable, step-by-step guidance through USCIS immigration applications. Individuals, attorneys and non-profits use the service on desktop or mobile device to prepare immigration forms accurately, avoiding costly delays. CitizenPath allows users to try the service for free and provides a 100% money-back guarantee that USCIS will accept the application or petition. We provide support for Green Card Renewal (Form I-90), the Citizenship Application (Form N-400), and several other popular forms.